one version of his death is given in the Robe Family History of Sarah Robe (David Robe's granddaughter) in the Descendants of Mary Currey Barker and John Baldwin. States that "When he was 22 years old, he left his father's home on Monday to give five miles away to do some plowing on a tract of land, about the end of the week he came home entirely insane and did not seem to know anything. Some persons went to see about the team, it was found hitched to a plow feeding in the field. He had plowed some, chopped some rail timber, supposed after he went crazy. The only cause that could be given, there had been a thunder storm, there was a tree struck in the field. He was said to be a bright young man. At one time he went about three miles from home as he had done before. He was advised to go home as it was getting dark and was cold. He started in that direction but was never seen again, it was supposed he wandered off into the mountains and perished."