Analysis. Is the William Walker who died at McCormicks Fort William 186?

Article Covers
Surnames
Walker
Places
Pennsylvania, United States
Huntingdon, Pennsylvania, United States
Year range
1750 - 1760

Contents


Return to Old Chester|Explanation

Walker Tapestry
Register
Data
Notebooks
Analysis
Bibliography
Graphics
Index
YDNA. Walker
Chalkley's

……………………..The Tapestry
Families Old Chester OldAugusta Germanna
New River SWVP Cumberland Carolina Cradle
The Smokies Old Kentucky



Sources

Notebook:References to the Killing of William Walker at McCormick's Fort, 1757

Related

Analysis. Location of McCormicks Fort on the Conodoguinet
person:William Walker (186)
person:William Walker (312)
person:Robert Walker (53)

Background

An account in the Pennsylvania Gazette of 13 May, 1757 notes that a William Walker was killed by Indians at McCormicks Fort on the Conodoguinet.

We'd like to know the identity of this William Walker. Some information we have on this KBI event is a one sentence statement in Source:Rupp, 1846

May 13, 1757, William Walker and another man were killed near McCormick's fort, at Conodoguinet

There is an additional entry in a Boston newspaper:

This gives us additional information, noting it was "near Shippensburgh", which is very close to Lurgan Township.

Newspaper record here (Ancestry Account Required) [1]

From this we can observe that

This William Walker probably died shortly before, or perhaps on May 13, 1757. This date is commonly cited as his DOD, but this maybe the date the newspaper was published, and the DOD itself may have been some days (perhaps weeks) prior to this.
The event occurred on the Conodoguinet, which places it somewhere in modern Cumberland County, or perhaps modern Franklin County.
It occurred "near" McCormicks Fort.
It occurred "near Shippensburgh", which is very close to Lurgan Township.
William Walker was probably an adult as the newspaper article states that he was killed with "another man". Had he been a child, that fact would probably have been mentioned and received emphasis in the article.

Location

The above suggests that the person we are looking for was an adult in 1757 and probably lived near "McCormicks Fort", on the Conodoguinet. A "McCormicks Fort" is known to have been constructed in 1778 in the Juanita River Basin [2] but its location in the Juanita River watershed, as well as the fact that it was constructed 20 years after the event discussed here seems to preclude it from being the "McCormicks Fort of Interest. Direct evidence for where McCormicks Fort was located "on the Conodoguinet is needed, but has not been found. We can, however, make some guesses as to its location. First, it was presumably located on the land of someone named "McCormick". There are several McCormicks in Cumberland County as it was defined in 1757, as revealed by land warrants See: Analysis:Location of McCormicks Fort on the Conodoguinet. Some of these warrants, such as that for William and Thomas McCormick, lay in what is now Juanita County, and can be excluded from consideration. Others' such as a warrant issued to Alexander McCormick, are too late (1762) to have been the site of McCormicks Fort.[3]

The best candidates for the settler on whose land McCormicks Fort was built are James McCormick on the Upper Conodoguinet (Franklin County), and John and Samuel McCormick on the Lower Conodoguinet. Given that the death was near Shippensburgh, the former possibility is more likely.

The William Walker who was killed at McCormick's fort was almost certainly William Walker of Lurgan Township based on a number of primary sources. Previous research assumed incorrectly it was another William Walker who also lived on the Conodoguinet in East Pennsboro Township.

Land Location

Warrant October 17, 1749.
Enlarge
Warrant October 17, 1749.
[4]
Land Survey on a modern map.
Enlarge
Land Survey on a modern map.
[5]


William Walker obtained a land grant near Shippensburgh.

Probate Records

William Walker's estate appears in court records in 1765, but the earliest reference to his death is in the Cumberland Administrator book A page 20. The index to this record survives, but the actual estate record has been lost. This location in the records would place his death around 1757 which is further supported by tax records.

William Walker's Probate Entry. Index is in chronological order, suggesting a death around 1757. Direct Link (Requires Ancestry Account)
Enlarge
William Walker's Probate Entry. Index is in chronological order, suggesting a death around 1757. Direct Link (Requires Ancestry Account)
[6]


His wife was named Mary, and he had at least four sons: John, Thomas, William, and Samuel according to court records

Cumberland County Orphan's Court Docket Volume 2, Pages 97-98
Cumberland County Orphan's Court Docket Volume 2, Pages 103-104

His son William cannot be the same William who lived in East Pennsboro, as land records indicate the children left the county after his death. John Walker lived in Charleston, Chester, Pennsylvania, his son Thomas Walker lived in Bedminster, New Jersey, and his son William Walker Jr. lived in Warrington, Bucks, Pennsylvania.

Cumberland Deed Book G, pages 113-115


Tax Records

William Walker can be found on early tax records in Cumberland, PA until 1758. Starting in 1758, the name "William Walker" is replaced with the name "Widow Walker", supporting the idea that he died around 1757 (and at McCormick's fort). Note this year that the list still includes William Walkers in Hopewell Township and East Pennsboro for 1758.

Cumberland County Archives

1750
East Pennsboro Township
William Walker
1751
Hopewell Township
William Walker
Lurgan Township
William Walker
1758 (Mislabeled as 1753)
East Pennsboro
William Walker
Hopewell Township
William Walker Sr
William Walker Jr
Lurgan Township
Widow Walker
Lurgan Township, 1751
Enlarge
Lurgan Township, 1751
Lurgan Township, 1758 (Mislabled as 1753)
Enlarge
Lurgan Township, 1758 (Mislabled as 1753)


[7]


References

  1. Codman, Ogden. Index of Obituaries In Boston Newspapers, 1704-1800: Boston Athenaeum. Boston: G. K. Hall, 1968. Volume 3 Page 507. Accessed though Ancestry.com U.S., Newspaper Extractions from the Northeast, 1704-1930 [database on-line]. Provo, UT, USA: Ancestry.com Operations, Inc., 2014.
  2. See: Source:Weiser, 1898 , and McCormicks Fort in Huntingdon County, PA.
  3. This ignores the possibility that Alexander was living on the land prior to securing a warrant. This seems unlikely, but can not be ruled out.
  4. Surveyed 1760. Book A-23 Page 194
  5. Done with the assistance of "First Families of Cumberland County", Hayes R. Eschenmann and Paul Barner, Cumberland County Historical Society. They can be obtained from the society here:
  6. Cumberland Probate Index T-Z: Ancestry.com. Pennsylvania, Wills and Probate Records, 1683-1993 [database on-line]. Provo, UT, USA: Ancestry.com Operations, Inc., 2015. Original data:Pennsylvania County, District and Probate Courts.
  7. Cumberland County Archives. "Tax Rates. 1736 to 1749. 1750, 1751, 1752, 1753" on spine. Transcription “of taxables was compiled from data contained in J. D. Rupp’s History of Cumberland and from a list published in the ‘American Volunteer’ May 1871…” written on the first page. (CCHS note indicates 1753 should be 1758.) Townships: Allen, Antrim, Carlisle (town), Guilford, Hamilton, Hopewell, Lurgan, Middleton, Pennsboro East, Pennsboro West, Peters. Index: CCHS compiled an index. Can be accessed here