I don't think Susie [b. 24 Jan 1839] is Moses and Martha's daughter. She would have been listed with them in the 1850 census, but isn't. Perhaps she's a niece?
In 1850, there is a Susana Massey living with her husband and children, born c.1815 living next door to Rebecca Shoemaker. Perhaps she's her daughter?
There is a Susie B. Massey, 2/23/1893-10/27/1976, along with several other Masseys buried in Dry Creek Cemetery. Perhaps it is this Susie, and the records I got were mistaken.