Person:Samuel Metcalf (6)
Samuel Metcalf
b.17 Sep 1668 Dedham, Norfolk, Massachusetts, United States
d.1690 Canada
Parents and Siblings
(edit)
m. 12 Sep 1656
  1. Sarah Metcalf1657/58 - 1701
  2. Mary Metcalf1660 - 1727
  3. Thomas Metcalf1665 - 1667/68
  4. Samuel Metcalf1668 - 1690
  5. Thomas Metcalf1671 - 1704
  6. John Metcalf1675 -
  7. Judith Metcalf1677 - 1682
Add Spouse and Children
Facts and Events
Name Samuel Metcalf
Gender Male
Birth[1][3] 17 Sep 1668 Dedham, Norfolk, Massachusetts, United States
Death? 1690 Canada
[edit]

Biography

Regarding the death date of This Samuel Metcalf please note he died 1690 on the Expedition to Canada. Let's look at these facts closely. Mary Metcalf his sister was baptized on 25 Nov 1660 in Dedham, the daughter of Deacon Thomas Metcalf and his wife Sarah [4]("Mary ye daughter of of brother Thomas Metchalf was baptized 25 9 1660." p 35}[5] She was the sister of Samuel Metcalf born in Dedham on Sept. 17, 1668 who died in Canada in 1690.[4]

She married John Fisher (1661-1755) on June 8, 1683 in Medfield, Norfolk, Massachusetts.[4] John Fisher (1661-1755) was born 2 Apr 1661 in Medfield, Norfolk, Massachusetts the son of John Fisher and Elizabeth Boylston (Fisher "John s. John and Elizabeth, APR. 2 1661." Medfield Births p 51).[6][4][7][8][4]

In 1690 during the expedition to Canada under Captain Andrew Gardner 60 men were lost. On 4 Jun 1736 the House of Representatives of Massachusetts constructed a list of heirs of these fallen soldiers to receive land grants in consideration of the loss to their families. The Grant known as Gardner's Canada would become incorporated later as Warwick. In the third list of grantees/heirs in the proprietors records we find "Samuel Fisher of Wrentham, eldest male heir to Samuel Metcalf." Samuel Metcalf was Samuel Fisher's brother-in-law. In other words Samuel Metcalf was the brother of Samuel Fisher's wife Mary (Metcalf) Fisher and son of Deacon Thomas Metcalf 1629 - 1702. (See Roster of the Expedition of 1690 to Canada, NEHGR Vol 99 1945 p 307 - 314)[4]

This information is extremely interesting in terms of the identity of Samuel Fisher's mother Mary (Metcalf) Fisher, wife of John Fisher. Mary Metcalf daughter of Deacon Thomas Metcalf was baptized in Dedham, Norfolk, Massachusetts in 25 NOV 1660.[5] She was the only Mary Metcalf to have a brother Samuel Metcalf. Samuel Metcalf was the second of the name. He was born on 17 Sep 1668 in Dedham, Norfolk, Massachusetts, and died in the expedition to Canada under Captain Andrew Gardner in 1690.[4] He had no children and hence his only heir was his brother-in-law Samuel Fisher who received the land grant described above.[4] This brings up two errors frequently encountered: 1) This Samuel died in 1690 not in 30 JUN 1713. The Samuel who died on 30 JUN 1713 in Dedham therefore had to be the young son of Thomas 1671 - 1704 and Sarah Avery i.e. his nephew. 2) The wife of John Fisher was not the Mary Metcalf daughter of John Metcalf 1622 - 1675 who was born 2 Jun 1668 in Medfiled. ("Medcalfe, Mary, d. John and Mary, June 2, 1668." p 71)[9] That Mary is therefore most certainly the Mary Metcalf who married Eleazar Ellis on on 26 Oct. 1687 in Medfield[9] because she had no brother Samuel so she could not have been the wife of John Fisher. These two errors are ubiquitous in the literature and on the Internet so I encourage the reader to look at these sources themselves.

She died on 16 Dec 1727 in Medfield, Norfolk, Massachusetts.("Fisher, Mary, w. John, Dec. 16, 1727." Medfield Deaths p 211)[10][4]

References
  1. ↑ Dedham (Massachusetts). Town Clerk; Julius Herbert Tuttle; Benjamin Fisher; and Don Gleason Hill. The early records of the town of Dedham, Massachusetts. (Dedham, Massachusetts: Dedham Transcript Press, 1886-1936)
    1:11.

    Sam., the Son of Thomas & Sary Metcalfe, borne the 17 of 7'br, 1668.

  2.   Dedham (Massachusetts). Town Clerk; Julius Herbert Tuttle; Benjamin Fisher; and Don Gleason Hill. The early records of the town of Dedham, Massachusetts. (Dedham, Massachusetts: Dedham Transcript Press, 1886-1936)
    1:37.

    Note he was not the Samuell Metcalf, deceased June ye 30, 1713 in this record. We know that this Samuel died in 1690 on the expedition to Canada and a land grant was given as compensation to his sister Mary wife of John Fisher.

  3. ↑ In the "Metcalf Genealogy", in NEHGR, p. 6:174, it says Samuel was born 17 Oct 1661, d. 30 Jun 1713. Besides the birth date not being found in Dedham Records S1, this article applies this same death date to two different Samuel Metcalfs, this one and Person:Samuel Metcalf (7). It can not belong to this Samuel as he died in Canada in 1690.
  4. ↑ 4.0 4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 4.5 4.6 4.7 4.8 Theodore F Jones, The New England Historical & Genealogical Register: Roster of the Expedition of 1690 to Canada (Boston, MA: NEHGS, Jan 1945), Volume 99 p 312 (" 44. "Samuel Fisher of Wrentham, eldest male heir to Samuel Metcalf." Samuel5 Fisher: b. Medfield, Sept. 29, 1685, d. Wrentham, Jan. 19, 1769, was the son of John4 Fisher, 1661-1755, and his wife Marys Metcalf (Thomas1), bpt. Dedham, Nov. 25, 1660, d. Medfield, Dec. 16, 1727, m. Medfield, June 8, 1683. Mary2 Metcalf was the sister of Samuel2 Metcalf, b. Dedham, Sept. 17, 1668, d. in Canada."). . link
  5. ↑ 5.0 5.1 Don Hill Gleason, A memorial volume. The record of baptisms, marriages and deaths, and admissions to the church and dismissals therefrom, transcribed from the church records in the town of Dedham, Massachusetts. 1638-1845 Also all the epitaphs in the ancient burial place in Dedham, together with the other inscriptions before 1845 in the three parish cemeteries (Dedham, Mass.: Dedham Transcript Press, 1886) Vol. 2 (Also referred to as Volume to of the Early Record of the town of Dedham in some genealogies) p 35 link
  6. ↑ Medfield, Norfolk, Massachusetts, United States. Vital Records of Medfield, Massachusetts, to the Year 1850. (Boston, Massachusetts: New England Historic Genealogical Society, 1903)
  7. ↑ Medfield, Norfolk, Massachusetts, United States. Vital Records of Medfield, Massachusetts, to the Year 1850. (Boston, Massachusetts: New England Historic Genealogical Society, 1903) p 52. ("Fisher, Samuel, s. John Jr. and Mary, Sept. 29, 1685.")
  8. ↑ Philip A Fisher, The Fisher Genealogy: Record of the Descendants of Joshua, Anthony, and Cornelius Fisher, of Dedham, Mass., 1630-1640. (Everett, Mass.: Massachusetts Pub. Co., 1898) p 31. John Fisher, s/o John Fisher and Elizabeth Boylston, b. Medfield 2 Apr 1661, d. 7 Nov 1755, m. (1) 8 Jun 1683 Mary Metcalf, m. (2) 1 Jul 1731 Sarah, widow of Ichabod Harding, and "probably" before that widow of Joseph Ellis of Dedham (and if so, maiden name Hemenway). p 50. ("Samuel Fisher, s/o John Fisher and Mary Metcalf, b. Medfield 29 Sep 1685, d. Wrentham 19 Jan 1769, m. 16 Dec 1707 Mary Rockwood. Will dated 17 Jun 1761, probated 24 Feb 1769, son John executor, his father's widow, four daughters, son Samuel, son Nathan.")
  9. ↑ 9.0 9.1 Medfield, Norfolk, Massachusetts, United States. Vital Records of Medfield, Massachusetts, to the Year 1850. (Boston, Massachusetts: New England Historic Genealogical Society, 1903) p 71 Births Metcalf(e) p 223 Deaths Metcalfe ("Medcalfe, Mary, d. John and Mary, June 2, 1668.") link
  10. ↑ Vital Records of Medfield, Massachusetts, to the Year 1850. (Boston, Massachusetts: New England Historic Genealogical Society, 1903) p 211. ("Fisher, Mary, w. John, Dec. 16, 1727." Medfield Deaths p 211)
Retrieved from "https://www.werelate.org/wiki/Person:Samuel_Metcalf_%286%29"