Person:Benjamin Melvin (1)

Benjamin Melvin
d.Bef 6 Jul 1748
m. Bef 1679
  1. John Melvin1679 -
  2. Hannah Melvin1681 -
  3. Robert Melvin1683/84 -
  4. James Melvin1685/86 -
  5. Jonathan Melvin1688 - 1736/37
  6. David Melvin1690 - 1745
  7. Benjamin Melvin1694/95 - Bef 1748
  • HBenjamin Melvin1694/95 - Bef 1748
  • W.  Lydia (add)
m. Bef 1723
  1. Lidiah Melvin1721 -
  2. _____ Melvin1723 -
Facts and Events
Name Benjamin Melvin
Gender Male
Birth[1] 17 Feb 1694/95 Charlestown, Suffolk, Massachusetts, United States
Marriage Bef 1723 to Lydia (add)
Death? Bef 6 Jul 1748
References
  1. Joslyn, Roger D. Vital Records of Charlestown, Massachusetts to the Year 1850. (Boston, MA: New England Historic Genealogical Society, 1984-1995)
    164.

    Beniamin Melvin, son of John & Hannah Melvin, b. Feb. 17, 1694/5.

  2.   Stearns, Ezra S.; William F. Whitcher; and Edward Everett Parker. Genealogical and Family History of the State of New Hampshire: a record of the achievements of her people in the making of a commonwealth and the founding of a nation. (New York: Lewis Publishing Company, 1908)
    Vol. 2, Page 667.

    "In 1717, as Lieutenant Benajmin Melvin, he was recorded as one of the proprietors of Ashford, Windham county, Connecticut. April 19, 1718 Anthony and David Stoddard, of Boston, as attorneys, sold for twenty seven pounds eight shillings, to Benjamin Melvin, blacksmith of Ashford, one hundred and thirty seven acres of land in Ashford. June 7, 1718, Benjamin Melvin sold to his father, John Melvin, of Concord, four acres of land in Concord. April 5, 1725, he, then of Ashford, sold for ninety one pounds, the tract of one hundred and thirty seven acres. In a deed dated January 10, 1726, he is described as now of Concord, Massachusetts. In 1726, Benjamin Melvin was one of the petitioners for the separation of the Carlisle, or north part of Concord, from the older part of the town, that the inhabitants might set up their own town meetings. July 23, 1740, "Benjamin Melvin, born in Charlestown, a blacksmith, aged forty five years," volunteered for the Spanish war in the West Indies, under Captain John Prescott. In all probabilitv this enlistment was from Concord where his last registration is found, and he must have been among those eighteen or more men who marched from that town of whom only a very few ever returned. He probably died while away, as no further record of him appears. The Ashford town books record that Benjamin Melvin and his wife Hannah had children born there: Lydia, and a daughter (Mary?) It is almost certain that he was the father of Benjamin..."

  3.   Estate of his brother David Melvin.

    Benjamin Melvin died sometime between 23 Jul 1740 when he enlisted for the Spanish War and 6 July 1748 when the distribution of his brother David's estate notes a description of land "bounded northwardly on Land Belonging to the Heirs of Benjamin Melven Dec'd."

  4.   Only two child are recorded with wife Lidiah ___ whom Benjamin must have married prior to 1721:

    Lidiah Melvin 4 JUN 1721 Ashford, Windham, Connecticut

    ___ Melvin 24 JUN 1723 Ashford, Windham, Connecticut

    There is no further record of either child and they likely died young.

    No further records so far links this Benjamin Melvin born 1694 to other children. While Benjamin Melvin c1728-1797 and Martha Melvin born c1738 who married Jacob Kemp may have been related there is no evidence they were his children. Interestingly both Benjamin Melvin c1728-1797 and Martha Melvin born c1738 have links to Chelmsford. Martha had children born in Chelmsford. Benjamin Melvin c1728-1797 in 1790 was warned out of Chelmsford with his wife Joanna: "Benjamin Melven and Joanna his wife from Nottingham in the County of Hillsborough and State of Newhampshier" NEHGR 83:166 and he certainly is the Benjamin who died in Nottingham, NH.

    The supposition is that Benjamin Melvin born 1694 died shortly after 23 Jul 1740 in the Spanish war. That certainly is possible. However, it isn't impossible that he married second to Mahitable Smead in 1732 and that he is identical to Benjamin Melvin of Winchester, NH who died there testate 20 Sep 1786 having children from 1733-1745. If so he had his first son Benjamin born in 1741 probably while he was at war. There is gap before the birth of his last son Moses in 1745. If this is the case he had a son Benjamin born 1741 who survived him and could not be the father of Benjamin born c1728-1797! And Benjamin of Winchester, NH left no provision for a daughter Martha Kemp or her many heirs.

    Which scenario is more likely and can we find dispositive evidence for one hypothesis?

    Indeed we can! In the division of his brother, David Melvin's estate on this page we find the description of land "bounded northwardly on Land Belonging to the Heirs of Benjamin Melven Dec'd," this being dated Concord July 6th, 1748 and all others of the name being still alive we can conclude that this Benjamin Melven died shortly after he enlisted in the Spanish War. Now to look up the deeds in Concord to see if there are ties to Benjamin and Martha as his surviving heirs...