Person talk:William Catcott (1)

Additional data on William Robert Catcott, etc. [4 June 2018]

"DataAnalyst"

Thanks for adding some data to William's page, and that of his siblings. Since they were far from my main interest, I would not have researched them any further. However, I resent the idea of anyone being dropped from the pages based on not finding data (Edwin). I have two sources that name him, w/o providing any details. They are Mary Meyers Williams and Larry Stoller. Stoller is not always correct on his names, but he has about 180,000 names in his database (which is not online). Stoller comes from a Tuscarawas County family. I assume that they both know far more about this family, than I ever will! Therefore, I see no basis for questioning the name at this time.

--White Creek 04:25, 4 June 2018 (UTC)

Hi

I would suggest you add your sources to Edwin's page - even if they are just mentions in someone else's tree. Without evidence, it is difficult to tell what is an error and what is true. Given the time period of this individual, I would have expected him to show up in a census record unless he died young, so, without any supporting evidence, it appeared to be a probable error. The delete warning was your opportunity to give feedback, as you have done. You can remove the delete template from the page.--DataAnalyst 23:52, 4 June 2018 (UTC)