Person talk:Noah Case (2)

Comment taken from front page:

"There is some confusion as to which Miriam Holcomb was married to Noah Case (b4oct1719, d28 Apr 1797). Miriam Holcomb and Noah Case were married 5 May 1740, but is it Miriam d/o Thomas Holcomb and Rebecca Pettibone or Miriam d/o Joshua Holcombe and Mary Hoskins. There is also another Miriam Holcomb d/o Joshua Holcomb and Ann Pettibone. All three were born about the same time. Sarah Holcomb d/o Joshua Holcombe and Mary Hoskins has also been listed as a wife. All are listing the same marriage date."

The above comments appear to be taken from a message forum. In response to this comment another member points out that there are not any records that show Thomas Holcombe and Rebecca Pettibone had a child named Miriam.

The comments also refer to a Miriam Holcomb d/o of Joshua Holcomb and Ann Pettibone. Records show John (not Joshua) Holcomb married to Ann Pettibone and they are not listed as having a daughter named Miriam either.

--Ronni 17:03, 18 August 2008 (EDT)