Goshen Township, Tuscarawas County, Ohio. HOH: Robert Carlisle, 24, b. in Scotland; h/o Bertha, 20, b. in Ohio; f/o James, 4, and Emma, 2. MIL EMMA STOCKLIN, 49, widowed. Emma is m/o 3 living children, married abt 1879 & married for 21y, b. Nov 1851 in Switzerland and her parents b. in Switzerland, emigrated in 1855.