1900 Census Cleveland Ward 20, Cuyahoga County, Ohio
Frank Sept. 1846 52 NY NY NY dentist Katherine Oct. 1864 35 3/3 PA, Scotland Scotland dentist Lillian M July 1883 17 Ohio NY PA Stella D Dec 1884 15 Ohio, NY, PA Octon Harrison W March 1881 19 Ohio, Rhode Island, PA bookmaker Dowd Rhoda July 1813 86 5/3 NY NY NY
↑ Benjamin's previous wife (Mary) called herself married in the 1900 census and divorced in the 1920 census (she is not easily found in the 1910 census). They must have been separated shortly after 1880, but it is not clear when they actually got divorced and when (and even whether) Benjamin marred Katherine. However, he appears to have been living with Katherine by about 1882.