"21. Capt. Nathaniel Sutliffe. Son of Serj. Nathaniel (4) and Sarah (Savage) Sutliffe, was born in Deerfield, Mass., in 1695. He married Hannah _____. He died January 7, 1760, in his 64th year. Hannah, his wife, died July 16, 1772, aged 92. Both are buried in the old cemetery In Durham, Conn. … The distribution of Nathaniel's estate (Middletown, Conn., Records), March 15, 1760, gives the estate of Capt. Nathaniel Sutliff as £2,143 8s. 4d. Distributed to his wife, Hannah, and his brothers and sisters.
Widow Judith Clark, £152 7s. 0d.
Joseph Sutliff, £152 7s. 0d.
Eunice Johnson, £ 152 7s. 0d.
Hannah Thomas, £152 7s. 0d.
Sarah Crittenden, £152 7s. 0d.
Heirs of John Sutliff, £152 7s. 0d.
Widow Mary How, £152 7s. 0d.
Heirs of Ann Clark, £152 7s. 0d.
At the General Assembly Holden in New Haven, Conn., Oct 14, 1731: This Assembly do establish and confirm Mr. Nathaniel Sutliff to be Capt. of the second company or train band at West Haddam and order that he be commissioned. (Colonial Records of Connecticut.)"