Family talk:Philip Taber and Mary Tomson (1)

Watchers

Source? [24 February 2014]

Was this page recreated simply to place the page that got deleted? Because it appears wrong and has no sources and it appears that it was good it got deleted? Mary has an overlapping marriage and so does Philip. --Jrich 19:47, 24 February 2014 (UTC)

Yes and no. In attempting to straighten out the Taber lines, the page needed to be replaced so as to have a position from which to work. From what I have been able to determine, it appears as if there were two Mary Thompsons and not one as this undeleted page would suggest. The 1st wife of Philip (no dates at present for her birth or death, so uncertain if this person is completely speculative or not) and the wife of his brother Thomas (the dates currently associated with this woman, sans the marriage estimate), which is where confusion appears to be deriving. To be frank, while I hesitate to completely delete this page due to the lack of immediate evidence, I would still like to attempt to ferret this connection from it's proverbial hole. Therefore, while the marriages as they currently stand are improbable if not down-right impossible, I propose to create a new Mary Thompson to at least clean-up the marriage issue until the Mary's may be proven out one way or the other.--Khaentlahn 20:57, 24 February 2014 (UTC)