"Jonathan (Atwater) … m 23 Jan 1744/5 (New Haven Vital Records), (Wallingford Vital Records) Sarah da. Elnathan & Abigail (Ufford) Beach.; … she m (2) 19 Dec 1765 (New Haven Vital Records) Ephraim Goldsmith; m (3) 29 July 1789 (church record, First Congregational Society, New Haven) Asahel Hall."