Elizabeth Gibbons was the second wife of James Warriner's father and the third wife of Elizabeth Baldwin's father.
"Dea. James Warriner, son of William (1) and Joanna, … married in Springfield, March 31, 1664, Elizabeth, daughter of Joseph Baldwin, the first settler of Milford, Mass. [Conn.]"
"James Warriner & Elisabeth Baldwin were maried March: 31: 1664:"