U.S. Federal Census 1870 Carroll County VA 35/35 Gardner James 19 mw Farmer Martha 21 fw Keeping House Elmer 10/12 mw b. Sept Goode Sarah 51 fw Goode Matilda 16 fw
.
U.S. Federal Census 1880 Carroll County VA 17/17 Gardner James wm 28 m Farmer Martha E. wf 31 w m Keeping House Elmer G. wm 10 s s Mary E. wf 8 d s Lucinda wf 6 d s Idelia P. wf 3 d s Cora L. wf 3/12 d s b. Feb Goode Sarah M. wf 65 ml w