Family:George Lewis and Mary Goodman (1)

Watchers
Facts and Events
Marriage[1] 7 Jun 1802 Willen, Buckinghamshire, England
Children
BirthDeath
1.
2.
3.
 
4.
5.

There are seven baptisms at Husborne Crawley between 1806 and 1814 where the parents' names are given as George and Mary. However, the gaps between the children are very small - in two cases less than nine months. Also, there is no sign of any of the children having died young, yet the seven baptisms include two children called Thomas and two called Susan / Susannah:

ch. 17 Feb 1806: Thomas

20 month gap

ch. 11 Oct 1808: Susannah

9 month gap

ch. 30 Jul 1809: George

7 month gap

ch. 25 Feb 1810: Susan

12 month gap

ch. 3 Feb 1811: Mary

18 month gap

ch. 1 Aug 1813: Thomas

8 month gap

ch. 10 Apr 1814: Henry

There was another couple called Lewis having children in Husborne Crawley at this time: Thomas and Martha. Only one baptism is recorded to them:

ch. 12 Mar 1818: James

However, they clearly had other children. Martha's probate records from 1829 makes clear that she had six children: Elizabeth, John, Mary, George, Thomas and James. The first three appear to have been born elsewhere before the family moved to Husborne Crawley: Elizabeth was baptised at Woburn, John at Eversholt, and Mary claimed in the census to have been born at Eversholt. In the censuses George and Thomas both gave their places of birth as Husborne Crawley, but no baptisms have been found there for them.

If we assume that the baptisms in 1809 of George and in 1813 of Thomas are incorrectly recorded and actually should have given the parents as Thomas and Martha rather than George and Mary this makes more sense of both families:

George & Mary children:

ch. 17 Feb 1806: Thomas

20 month gap

ch. 11 Oct 1808: Susannah

16 month gap

ch. 25 Feb 1810: Susan

12 month gap

ch. 3 Feb 1811: Mary

26 month gap

ch. 10 Apr 1814: Henry

Thomas & Martha children:

b. 3 Mar 1800 (at Woburn): Elizabeth

ch. 30 Jun 1805 (at Eversholt): John

b. abt 1806 (at Eversholt according to census): Mary

ch. 30 Jul 1809: George

ch. 1 Aug 1813: Thomas

ch. 12 Mar 1818: James

The idea that the George in 1809 and Thomas in 1813 belonged to Thomas and Martha is supported by the fact that no later trace can be found of a George from around 1809 other than the one who gave his father's name as Thomas when he married, whilst both Thomases (1806 and 1813) can be found in the 1851 census - Thomas 1806 at Little Brickhill and Thomas 1813 in London.

This solution is still not perfect; there are still two Susans, with no sign of a burial for the first before the second was born, neither is claimed for Thomas and Martha by Martha's probate records and no plausible Susan can be found in the later censuses. However, it is considered based on the analysis above that we can be confident that the George baptised in 1809 and Thomas in 1813 belonged to Thomas Lewis and Martha Drinkwater, not George Lewis and Mary Goodman.

References
  1. Marriages register, in Church of England. Willen Parish Registers, 1665-1981. (Aylesbury: Centre for Buckinghamshire Studies).

    Banns of Marriage between George Lewis & Mary Goodman both of this Parish were thrice duly published in this Church & no Impediment alledged
    George Lewis of this Parish Batchelor & Mary Goodman of this Parish were married in this Church by Banns this seventh day of June in the Y[ea]r of our Lord One Thousand eight hundred & Two by me Tho[ma]s Gardner, Curate
    This Marriage was solemnized between us} George Lewis's Mark X / Mary Goodman's Mark X
    In the Presence of John Knight