This source lists the birth order as: Beneke (ABT 1578), Hans (ABT 1580), Tönnies (ABT 1582), Albin (ABT 1584), Diedrich (ABT 1586). (Here we learn that "Alb." means Albin rather than Albert.)
DISCREPANCY: Source 1 has the family in Groß Nenndorf, Source 2 in Klein Nenndorf.