.... 2 [1] Joseph Caldwell b: 8 Aug 1777 d: 1864
........ +Anne E. Pugh d: 11 Jun 1864
.... *2nd Wife of [1] Joseph Caldwell:
........ +Mary Roberts Yarnall d: Unknown
.... *3rd Wife of [1] Joseph Caldwell:
........ +Catherine Ross Thompson d: Unknown
.... *4th Wife of [1] Joseph Caldwell:
........ +Mary Harrall d: Unknown
https://www.ancestry.com/boards/surnames.caldwell/299/mb.ashx