[Sarah Tinker (so-called)] married at Lyme, Connecticut, 17 Jun 1686, Jonathan Hudson, who was supposedly born 8 May 1658. There were Hudsons in Lyme and Southold 1680-1700, but a genealogy of the family has not yet been compiled.
Jonathan Hudson died on Shelter Island 5 April 1729 and was buried in the Sylvester Manor Cemetery there, aged 71. He left an unrecorded will on Shelter Island, dated 2 April 1729, proved 10 April 1729.