"Gamaliel Butler (John, John, Nicholas), b. 1692; res. E[dgartown], (Plain) farmer. He m. (1) Anna Vincent (21) 11 Apr. 1732, who was b. 1713; m. (2) Mercy Dunham (498) 5 Dec. 1748, who was b. 1716 and d. Feb. 1801. He d. Feb.-June 1765 and his est. was adm. in 1765 and finally settled in 1787."