"Riley, Eunice, daughter of Jonathan & Euncie, died May 4, 1732, age 17 yrs."
Strongly suspect that the year of death was misread or otherwise inaccurately recorded, and should be 1752. Jonathan and his second wife had daughter Eunice 5 November 1734 who would have turned seventeen on 5 November 1741. Jonathan's first marriage, to Sarah Wilcox, did not occur until 1716.