Children of John with wife Mary Smith:, Philana b. 28 Apr 1868, didn't marry, Ezra b. 1 May 1870, married Cecia Haight, Elizabeth, b. 30 Apr 1872, married Robert Albrant, Elijah, b. 29 Jan 1875, married Bessie (unknown), Joseph, b. 16 Feb 1877, married Gladys McDonald, Bertha, b. 5 Aug 1879, married Thomas McKibbin, Mary Isabelle, b. 4 Feb 1882, d. 1883, Frederick, b. 22 Nov 1883, d. 7 Sept 1972, married Mary McKibbin on 4 Nov 1908 (Mary and Thomas McKibbin were brother and sister), Edith, b. 4 Nov 1886, didn't marry.